After analyzing the records of the second public examination
of Joan, which took place on Thursday, February 22, 1431, I am beginning to
further quantify the accusers’ questions posed to Joan. While I have not yet
determined an overall pattern of the Trial, the second public examination asked
noticeably fewer question than the remaining third, fourth, fifth, and sixth
public examinations. Only 11 questions were posed to Joan in the second public
examination, however the transcript from the day is relatively lengthy in light
of how little was recorded as having been asked. Interestingly enough, Joan is
recorded as having given away a multitude of information during the second
public examination, including having heard the voice from God beginning at age
13, although she is not asked many questions leaving one to assume Joan
willingly afforded her accusers damaging information.
Of the 11 questions asked within the second public
examination, four were concerned with background and childhood information, five
asked about religious imagery/visions, one question focused on her allegiance
to the French (particularly to King Charles VII), and one regarding her male
dress. I will be utilizing this source within the primary source analysis paper
as well, in order to better explore its stark differences between the other public
examination records.
That is rather interesting. Were the questions of examination two asking to elaborate from examination one? Perhaps this could explain the lengthiness of this examination versus the others.
ReplyDeleteHi Rachel!
ReplyDeleteIt's interesting that the examiner(s) were so curious about her religious visions. Do you think that the focus of the examinations will change over time? Or do you think that they will all primarily focus on her visions and childhood?