Christianity and Buddhism developed separately from each
without any possibilities of one influencing or affecting the other. Tillich
had the chance to not only converse with Zen Buddhism scholars in the U.S. but
also the chance to visit Japan for two months in a “intellectual exchange”
(Boss, 262). There are some fundamental differences, as one could guess,
between Christianity and Buddhism. Aside from the obvious being and nonbeing,
these differences rested on the principle of participation and the principle of
identity for Tillich. “One participates, as an individual human being, in the
Kingdom of God. One is identical with everything that is in Nirvana” (Tillich,
68). A relationship between self and God is not really possible in Buddhism due
to everything and everyone being
identical while everyone and
everything could not participate in the ultimate in Buddhism as “I am thou”
(Boss, 257). Boss italicized on purpose to highlight the different focus
between the two religions and made for a clear contrast. It is important to
note that the “I” does not cancel out the “thou” in Buddhism. “Any exclusively
undifferentiated non-duality in which everything is reduced to a sheer sameness
is branded a false sameness” (Tillich, 142). Tillich admitted having trouble
understanding “how the individual is simultaneously preserved and not preserved”
(Tillich, 148). This contrast between the Western and Eastern religions still
essentially focuses on the same question of existence. One focuses on the
individual and through the individual one finds existence. The other focuses on
everything else but the individual and through nonbeing one will exist.
Boss, Marc. Tillich in dialogue with Japanese Buddhism.
Edited by Re Manning, Russell. The Cambridge Companion to Paul Tillich.
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2009.
Tillich, Paul. Christianity and the Encounter of the World
Religions. New York City: Columbia University Press, 1963.



